Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Swag Valance's avatar

Re: “researchers at Stanford and Google created a simulated mini-town called Smallville, and asked the 25 AI inhabitants to organise a birthday party”, I’m way less optimistic than you are.

This is basically what’s called “agent based modeling” in complex adaptive systems circles. For example, SFI’s Complexity Explorer has offered courses using NetLogo programming for years. While simulations can layer in more complex rules and numbers of agents, the main shortcoming is that it’s nothing like the predictive modeling most people expect.

Initial conditions and the non-linear, emergent, and self-organizing behaviors can create very different outcomes with each simulation run. The best predictive analyses thus come down to Monte Carlo-level mass simulations, hoping to draw out some select aggregation of scenarios happening more probabilistically than others. Thus it’s less like predicting the weather and more like the ever-flawed AI simulations of who will win the World Cup - the latter of which is frequently outdone by octopuses and armadillos.

I sincerely doubt this is the anticipated outcome you’re excited about. But there’s still magic in the uncertainty despite our best analytical efforts.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts